Just Pies: Indulge in Exquisite Pies in Westerville, OH

I hesitate to leave this review because the more people that know about it, the more likely they will be sold out of my favorite pie! They have a wide selection of small, med, and large pies. They also have a nice selection of delicious no sugar added pies. Pies come in frozen or fresh! Everything we have tried has been amazing. Highly recommend!

There is absolutely no equal to these amazing pies. A great wide selection, and even amazing meat pies. I recently had a chicken pot pie from their, and it was absolutely the best chicken pot pie I had ever had! the triple berry pie as well as the bumbleberry pie are two excellent options

Fabulous pies. You smell them when you walk in the door. Really nice ladies and a wide variety of pies. Pre Thanksgiving is a long wait in line and some pies are out. But tasty pies are worth it.

Pies are delicious, service is great! Normally don't think of them for Valentine's Day, but wanted something different for my daughters and wife than normal chocolate, etc. So stopped here, bought pies for everyone, and they were a huge hit.

The buckeye pie was exceptionally delicious! I enjoy eating it semi-frozen. The peach pie was okay—crust delicious; peaches could have been more tender as they were somewhat crunchy; not a big fan of commercial pies with gel-type fruit filling; taste was perfect… not too sweet. I will probably just stick with the cream pies. The chicken pot pie had a delicious homemade taste, but for whatever reason, the chicken had a “chickeny” smell— it didn’t taste spoiled, but the smell was off— I will not purchase again The turkey pot pie also had a delicious homemade taste—I will definitely purchase again. I cannot wait to try the key lime pie with whipped topping instead of meringue (with advanced order). I really appreciate that they sell small pies.

All their fruit pies are wonderful. Blueberry is my daughter's favorite. My favorite is the apple crumb.

I recently had Just Pies for the first time. As someone whose been to Key West and the Florida Keys many times, this definitely is just as good or better than most Key Lime pies I've had. The balance of tart and cream is perfectly balanced in the middle. The whipped cream is big but light tasting. And the crust is perfectly fresh and flakey. Thanks to Frank Carl of Genoa Baptist Church for bringing us the pie and introducing us to Just Pies

I have to give these guys five stars just based on the line out the door. There are few places I have visited that gets this kind of loyalty from its customers. Unfortunately I did not realize how popular the pies were and opted not to wait in line. But now way can they be anything but fantastic and will get my chance to try them, just maybe not right before Thanksgiving.